Facebook
Notification
Redland Bayside News
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
Facebook
Notification
Redland Bayside News
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
Redland Bayside News > Featured > OPINION: Has Australia taxed cigarettes into the hands of criminals?
FeaturedFederal Politics

OPINION: Has Australia taxed cigarettes into the hands of criminals?

Andrew Jefferson
Andrew Jefferson
Published: August 6, 2026
Share
3 Min Read
Illegal vapes are displayed during a press conference to addresses the media to discuss the NSW Government’s $6.8 million investment to crackdown on illegal vape imports and for more support programs. Sydney, Monday September 25, 2023. (AAP Image/Bianca De Marchi) NO ARCHIVING
SHARE

The raid and closure notice issued to Cleveland business Fashion Spree this week should prompt more than another round of tough talk about illicit tobacco and vapes.

It should prompt an uncomfortable question for Canberra.

Has the Federal Government pushed cigarette taxes so high that it has helped create the black market it is now struggling to contain?

No one should pretend alleged illegal sales are acceptable. They are not.

- Advertisement -

If businesses are found to be selling illicit cigarettes or vapes, they should face the full force of the law.

Tobacco products sold outside the legal system are unregulated, untaxed and increasingly linked to organised crime.

But enforcement alone is plainly not fixing the problem. The shop in Bloomfield Street ripped off its closure notice 90 minutes later and resumed sales.

A legal pack of 20 cigarettes now carries about $30.57 in federal excise alone, before GST.

On a packet costing more than $40, the government’s tax take is roughly $34.

Meanwhile, illegal cigarettes can be bought for a fraction of that price – often a tenner.

That enormous price gap is not an accident.

It is the direct result of a public-health strategy designed to make smoking prohibitively expensive.

The strategy has had important benefits.

Smoking rates have fallen dramatically over the past two decades, and fewer young Australians are taking up the habit.

But policy has consequences — including unintended ones.

When the legal product costs three or four times more than its illicit equivalent, a black market does not merely emerge. It becomes exceptionally profitable.

That profit attracts criminal networks, puts legitimate retailers under pressure and leaves police, Australian Border Force and health officers in a constant game of catch-up.

The allegations surrounding Fashion Spree, and the wider string of closures and raids in the Redlands and Brisbane, are a local symptom of a national failure.

It is not enough for governments to seize stock, shut stores and issue warnings if another outlet simply opens, or allegedly resumes trading 90 minutes later.

Canberra should not abandon its anti-smoking agenda.

But it should honestly review whether the current excise settings are reducing smoking or merely shifting more sales into the underground economy.

A carefully calibrated reduction — paired with tougher licensing, stronger border enforcement and severe penalties for illicit traders — could narrow the price gap and make legal products more competitive against bootleg cigarettes.

The aim should not be to make smoking cheap. It should be to stop making criminal tobacco so lucrative.

Until the Federal Government confronts that reality, raids like the one in Cleveland may keep making headlines — while the black market keeps counting the cash.

Share This Article
Facebook Email Print

Latest Redlands News

COMING TOGETHER: Rehearsals for Rock Choir at QPAC in November are underway at the Donald Simpson Centre, Cleveland.
Redland Rock Choir gets ready to sizzle at QPAC
Entertainment
FOLLOW-UP MATTERS: Follow-up appointments are where early problems are sorted out properly.
Follow-up appointments bring opportunity for vital fine-tuning
Sound Decisions
SWEET VICTORY: CC’s Boutique Patisserie promotes a selection of tasty treats.
Readers crown CC’s as Cleveland’s reigning queen of the sweet treats
Ash's Apetite
BREAKING POINT: The Reserve Bank of Australia’s recent decision to increase the cash rate to 4.85 per cent has increased the pressure.
Renters warned against being forgotten as interest rates rise
Real Estate
GETTING OUT: Tanya Doko and James Roche are taking Bachelor Girl on the road to regional venues.
Bachelor Girl’s reimagined album on regional road trip
Entertainment Featured
JOY IN GIVING: Redland Community Centre is coordinating some festive help for struggling families.
GIVE A CHILD SOME CHRISTMAS JOY
Community Featured
HIGH HOPES: Lord Mayor Adrian Schrinner and Brisbane Airport CEO Gert-Jan de Graaff.
Metro call as airport readies for $5b upgrade
Business

You Might Also Like

PHOTOS: Dylan Buckee
CommunityFeatured

Quandamooka designers shine on First Nations fashion runway

August 14, 2025
FeaturedRedland City Council

Call for Beveridge Rd flood action as Thornlands residents raise drainage concerns

August 14, 2026
CommunityFeaturedState Politics

Field backs Buy Smart as practical lesson in money and consumer rights

February 4, 2026
Brisbane body found
CommunityFeaturedPolice

Murder, attempted rape accused to face fresh charges

October 2, 2025

Published by Local News Group QLD. Dedicated to connecting local communities through informative and engaging media.

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Quick Links
  • Community
  • Featured
  • Sport
  • Cleveland
  • Redland City Council
  • Real Estate
  • Seniors
  • Capalaba
  • Business
  • Redlands
  • Redland Bay
  • Victoria Point
  • Birkdale
  • Entertainment
  • Fishing
  • Wynnum
  • Wellington Point
  • Alexandra Hills
  • Finance
  • Disability News
Copyright © 2026 Local News Group - Website by LNG Digital
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?