Facebook
Notification
Redland Bayside News
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
Facebook
Notification
Redland Bayside News
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • News & Editorial
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
  • Advertise With Us
  • Digital Editions
  • Pickup Locations
Redland Bayside News > Featured > EDITORIAL: A dress rehearsal for Steady Hands
FeaturedRedland City Council

EDITORIAL: A dress rehearsal for Steady Hands

Andrew Jefferson
Andrew Jefferson
Published: November 18, 2026
Share
9 Min Read
SHARE

The final Redland City Council meeting before the mayoral by-election was always going to be more than an ordinary day in the chamber.

It was a dress rehearsal.

For Acting Mayor Julie Talty, it was an opportunity to show Redlands voters what “Steady Hands” looks like in practice.

Not in a campaign video, but in the chair, under pressure, with a long agenda and a chamber full of competing personalities.

- Advertisement -

And, on Wednesday, she passed the test.

Cr Talty was visibly on her best behaviour.

She was patient, measured and careful with standing orders, allowing debate to breathe even when it wandered.

It was a different register from the sharper chairing Redlands residents have sometimes seen before.

Cr Paul Bishop took full advantage of the latitude.

Across almost every substantial agenda item, Cr Bishop offered lengthy statements of opinion framed as questions.

The questions were usually there eventually, but not before a preamble, a theory or an invitation for officers to revisit ground already dealt with in the report.

Councillors must be able to challenge staff, test assumptions and seek assurances. That is their job. But a Bishop question often tends to be a lengthy tedious speech with a question mark at the end.

In normal circumstances, Cr Talty would have brought Cr Bishop sharply back to relevance much earlier.

On Wednesday, she let him run.

It made for a longer meeting, but perhaps that was the point.

Cr Talty showed voters a chair prepared to absorb criticism without instantly turning the chamber into another argument about process.

It was steady hands in progress.

Rival mayoral candidate Cr Rowanne McKenzie was more subdued, but her approach carried its own message.

At several points, she attempted to pull Cr Bishop back from his more meandering interventions, using the rules and the platform available to her.

It was a useful contrast.

Cr Talty playing the calm chair, Cr McKenzie signalling that she would demand tighter discipline in the big seat.

One reliable source has told this newspaper Cr Bishop once described the council chamber as “merely a stage” and councillors as “all actors”.

We have not independently verified the exact wording, but the sentiment certainly had resonance on Wednesday.

If the chamber is a stage, then Cr Bishop gave a long performance.

And it needed a hook from Steady Hands much earlier.

The real issue, however, was not the theatre. It was the work.

A petition seeking reconfigured parking at Victoria Point Jetty was referred to the chief executive. That is a proper first step, but the community will judge Council on whether a referral becomes an actual solution.

The outstanding-business list carried much weight.

Birkdale Community Precinct remains unresolved, as do promised reports into persistent water-supply interruptions in parts of Mount Cotton/Capalaba and flooding and drainage impacts around Beveridge Road, Thornlands.

These are not matters to be endlessly noted and revisited. They affect whether residents have reliable water, whether homes and roads flood and whether Council can earn confidence on the city-shaping Birkdale precinct.

The financial report contained both reassurance and a warning.

Council reported an operating surplus of $65.5 million, $5.7 million ahead of budget. That is welcome. But it also reported spending just $9.4 million on renewing infrastructure against $25 million in depreciation, leaving its asset sustainability ratio below target.

A council can post a healthy operating result and still fall behind on the maintenance of roads, buildings and public assets. Surplus is not the same thing as sustainability.

The quarterly operational-plan report painted a more positive picture, with 110 of 112 actions listed as on track and two completed. That is encouraging, but “on track” is not a completed outcome. Residents should expect regular reporting and proof that those actions improve everyday life.

The annual review of CEO delegations and the appointment of disaster-management proxies may not excite many readers, but both mattered. With a severe-weather season under way, Council needs governance arrangements that work without fuss or delay.

The Koala Coast Ecotourism Trail debate was another exercise in managing expectations. This reporter received a gentle rap on the knuckles when Steady Hands and Cr Peter Mitchell (who had not even seen our media report) insisted the project was not on hold, and they are technically right – the feasibility work found no fatal flaw.

But neither is the trail ready to build.

Council has endorsed a pathway involving stronger tracks-and-trails governance, better data, asset planning, funding partnerships and eventually a business case. That is sensible groundwork. It becomes a real tourism legacy only when it is followed by money, milestones and delivery.

The same applies to the proposed Southern Moreton Bay Islands-to-Raby Bay passenger ferry.

Council unanimously backed advocacy for State Government consultation and feasibility work. That was the right limited decision. A direct connection could improve access to rail, jobs, health services and Cleveland businesses, building on SeaLink’s recent demonstration service.

But Council approved advocacy, not a ferry service or a financial commitment.

Member for Redlands Rebecca Young is right to warn that island residents do not want another study gathering dust. A practical commuter trial, Raby Bay Harbour infrastructure and unresolved leasing arrangements must progress alongside Council’s advocacy. Otherwise, “connectivity” will remain a good idea with no boat attached.

The Woodbury Town Centre application at Double Jump Road, Victoria Point, was a reminder that Council still faces consequential planning choices. A proposed supermarket, specialty retail and associated centre uses must be assessed against traffic, environmental impacts and the integrity of the city’s existing centres.

That is where councillors need concise, evidence-based scrutiny not political monologues.

Council’s support for a lease to help Redland Bay Tennis Club pursue three pickleball courts was a welcome community outcome. It gives volunteers a chance to seek funding and advance planning, while retaining the necessary checks around noise, landowner consent and the former landfill site.

That is what practical Council support should look like. A path forward, not a false promise that the courts are already built.

The electricity easement for lighting upgrades at EGW Woods Sportsfield was another quieter but important decision. It will help turn funding into actual community sporting infrastructure.

The Redlands Coast 2032 Legacy Working Group reported back, too. The city should welcome serious thinking about Olympic and Paralympic legacy, but it must be more than a gathering of respected names and meeting summaries. Redlands needs tangible benefits in transport, facilities, participation and investment.

Then came the usual confidential items. Signature-event funding, a land concession, Minjerribah property management, a Macleay Island lease, Victoria Point Library leasing arrangements and the 2026 remuneration review.

Some confidentiality is lawful and necessary. But Council owes residents clear explanations of the decisions made once those restrictions no longer apply.

Wednesday’s meeting was not perfect. It was too long in places, too indulgent of statements masquerading as questions and too willing to let process become performance.

But it was also a reminder that the chamber can function when the person in the chair refuses to turn every irritation into a fight.

Julie Talty used the final meeting before the mayoral by-election to show voters a version of her leadership based on composure, patience and control.

Cr Bishop showed why that control is needed.

Today’s performance may be over. The real test begins when the votes are counted next month.

Share This Article
Facebook Email Print

Latest Redlands News

Travel Insurance Pitfalls to Check Before Your Next Trip
Travel insurance – read the fine print before you fly
Travel
An aerial view of Mount Cotton.
German reminders in the Redlands
Back in the day
Redland Bay pickleball courts get unanimous council backing
Featured Redland City Council
Why a Family Emergency Plan Matters During Storm Season
A family plan could save lives
Community
$5M Koala Trail ‘not on hold’, councillors insist
Featured Redland City Council
STRONG COMMITMENT: Education is about more than what happens inside a classroom.
Y Schools believe in educating for life, not just in the classroom
Education
Council backs ferry study as MP urges practical action
Featured Redland City Council

You Might Also Like

Mr O’Connor joined Mangrove Housing staff to break ground on the construction.
CommunityFeatured

New community housing will give older women safe refuge

November 21, 2024
CommunityFeaturedRedland City Council

ONE NAME ON PETITION: Holloway push yet to gain traction

March 25, 2026
WASTE NOT: Green bins are proving popular for recycling.
CommunityFeatured

Residents waste no time in using green bin service

June 13, 2024
CommunityFeaturedPoliceState Politics

New website targets Redlands hoons

March 13, 2026

Published by Local News Group QLD. Dedicated to connecting local communities through informative and engaging media.

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Quick Links
  • Community
  • Featured
  • Sport
  • Cleveland
  • Redland City Council
  • Real Estate
  • Seniors
  • Capalaba
  • Business
  • Redlands
  • Redland Bay
  • Victoria Point
  • Birkdale
  • Entertainment
  • Fishing
  • Wynnum
  • Wellington Point
  • Finance
  • Alexandra Hills
  • Disability News
Copyright © 2026 Local News Group - Website by LNG Digital
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?